Public Safety

Accidental shootings by police expose training shortfalls

Fatal shooting of Burlington's Autumn Steele among those studied

In this Jan. 6, 2015, still frame taken from police body camera video, Gabe Steele, left, reacts after his wife, Autumn
In this Jan. 6, 2015, still frame taken from police body camera video, Gabe Steele, left, reacts after his wife, Autumn Steele, was accidentally shot and killed by a Burlington police officer responding to a domestic dispute call near the couple’s home in Burlington. Accidental shootings by police happen across the United States every year, an Associated Press investigation has found. In this case, the officer was cleared of any wrongdoing and returned to the force. (Burlington Police Department via AP)
/

When an Iowa mother tried to take her child from her husband during an argument on a snowy sidewalk in 2015, a Burlington officer stepped in to stop the scuffle. But he accidentally fired his weapon as a dog approached, killing the woman as the family he had come to help watched in horror.

When a Minnesota sergeant stopped a motorcyclist after a 2015 high-speed chase, he stepped out of his patrol car with his gun drawn, flush with adrenaline, and accidentally shot the man in the arm.

And an Arkansas police officer fatally shot a suspect in 2012 as she tried to get him into handcuffs.

Accidental shootings by law enforcement have happened at agencies small and large and at all levels — city, county, state and federal — in recent years across the United States, an Associated Press investigation has found. They’ve caused hundreds of injuries to officers, their partners, suspects and bystanders. Sometimes, they’ve caused deaths.

Although the situations widely differ, experts say the reason does not: Officers don’t get the training they need to handle their guns proficiently, especially in life-or-death situations.

The methods used to train officers with their firearms “create the illusion of learning” but are inadequate for the demands of policing, said Bill Lewinski, executive director of the Illinois-based Force Science Institute, which provides research and training to law enforcement.

Officers are most proficient with their guns immediately after finishing a police academy, experts say. After that, most are tested only once or twice a year in “qualifications” that measure a minimum level of firearms proficiency. There are no federal guidelines for these tests, so there are thousands of different standards.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

No one tracks these shootings nationwide, so the AP collected media reports and surveyed agencies across the country through public records requests. The review was not comprehensive due to the sheer number of U.S. law enforcement agencies and a lack of reporting requirements for such shootings. But the research provides a snapshot of the problem, documenting 1,422 unintentional discharges since 2012 at 258 agencies.

The tally includes any incident in which a gun went off and the officer didn’t intend it to, whether someone was cleaning or unloading the weapon or rather surging with adrenaline while responding to a call. Some shootings occurred because of muscle reflexes, experts said, or because the officer simply tripped.

Countless law enforcement officers safely perform their duties every day, but some experts say even a small number of accidental shootings is unacceptable because they’re preventable.

“Ninety-nine out of 100 times, there is not something wrong with the gun,” said Paul Markel, a former police officer and firearms instructor in Mississippi. “It’s the person holding it.”

In the 2015 Iowa case, Autumn Steele was arguing with her husband and trying to grab their 3-year-old son from him outside their Burlington home when Officer Jesse Hill approached. The husband, Gabe Steele, had called 911.

But the couple’s dog darted toward Hill, and he lost his balance and fired two shots as he fell backward in the snow.

One bullet hit the dog. The other hit 34-year-old Autumn Steele, killing her.

The AP found 21 cases like this where people died in accidental shootings by police. It identified another 134 cases where the officer injured himself, and 45 where an accidental discharge injured another officer. An officer accidentally shot and injured bystanders in 34 instances and suspects in 19.

Unintentional shootings typically lead to two investigations: An outside agency determines if charges should be filed, and an internal review examines whether policies were violated and punishment such as suspension is appropriate.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

In Autumn Steele’s case, a prosecutor compared the evidence against Iowa’s homicide statutes and decided Hill could not be charged.

Steele’s family filed a wrongful-death suit against the officer and city and reached a $2 million settlement.

Police have succeeded in keeping a body camera recording of the shooting, except for a brief clip, secret from the public under Iowa’s open records law. However, a federal court released it anyway since it was evidence in the family’s wrongful death suit.

Burlington police body camera video shows events surrounding the 2015 fatal shooting of Autumn Steele

Hill later returned to the force and his attorney did respond to a request for comment from the AP.

Gabe Steele, 40, thinks Hill should have been held accountable.

“He just got to go on vacation and get paid for it, for taking my son’s mother away,” Steele told the AP. “No one has ever apologized to me and my son. That hurts.”

Agencies have different terms for these shootings, including “accidental,” “negligent,” or “unintentional” discharges.

After the federal court released the body camera video in 2018, The Gazette asked three experts to view it and offer their opinions. One said Hill should not have fired unless he knew what was behind his target of the attacking dog; another said he would have acted as Hill did; and the third said he’d give any benefit of the doubt to Hill.

The officer said he had slipped in the snow.

Doug Tangen, firearms program manager at Washington state’s law enforcement training center, argues all three shootings were caused by a degree of negligence, because at some point the officer violated one or more of the four universal safety rules:

Assume all guns are loaded; always point the muzzle in a safe direction; keep your finger off the trigger, and be sure of your target and what is beyond it.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

In some of the cases reviewed by the AP, the officer was hyped up due to adrenaline, which can severely impair the senses. Other accidental shootings have been attributed to muscle reflexes — one hand or arm jerks or contracts, causing the other hand or arm to jerk or contract also.

Experts agree the way to reduce them is to rethink training, starting with the amount required.

While all academies require cadets to undergo a certain number of hours of firearms instruction, the AP found how many vary widely.

Georgia, Illinois and Indiana, for example, call for 40 hours of specific firearms training.

Washington state requires 90, but once officers go to work for a department, the amount of additional training they receive is uncertain, said Sean Hendrickson, an instructor at the Washington State Criminal Justice Training Commission, which trains the state’s police and sheriff’s deputies.

Another issue is the type of training used. Most academies employ “block and silo” methods, which bombard officers with information and make it difficult to retain, experts say.

What’s lacking are standards for firearms training at the academy and throughout an officer’s career.

Some private firearms training companies have responded by offering free classes for law enforcement.

Missouri-based My Brothers 6 sells T-shirts to help fund training for officers through another group, Shield Solutions. Lighthouse Tactical, based in Alabama, offers similar deals.

“The basic training an officer receives at the police academy is a base to work from,” said Lighthorse owner Curt Carpenter, a retired officer. “The problem is that the academy is often all the training an officer gets.”’

———

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

More on AP’s findings: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/6570974/Accidental-shootings-by-police.pdf

Agency-by-agency breakdown: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/6569278/Spreadsheet.pdf

Give us feedback

We value your trust and work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage. If you have found an error or omission in our reporting, tell us here.

Or if you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.

Give us feedback

We value your trust and work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage. If you have found an error or omission in our reporting, tell us here.

Or if you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.