Iowa City approves first of three readings of 21-ordinance

Opponents of a possible 21-and-older bar law had their say Tuesday night, but the City Council had the votes.

Next fall, however, those opponents hope the roles are reversed.

The council, as expected, approved the first of three readings of an ordinance banning those younger than 21 from being in bars after 10 p.m. Currently, people 19 and older are allowed in Iowa City bars at night.

If approved twice more, the law would take effect June 1.

The vote was 6-1, with Regenia Bailey against. The majority said that after years of other measures failing to stop problem drinking, the so-called 21-only law offered the best chance to finally make a difference.

“We don't have an alcohol culture, we have an overindulging culture,” said Connie Champion, who until this year had always opposed 21-only. “And I do blame the bar owners.”

About 80 people were in council chambers and the lobby of City Hall. About three-fourths of the 25 who spoke were against the proposal.

Most of the opponents were college-aged people. They argued that binge drinking isn't limited to those younger than 21, that the law would hurt bars financially and cost student jobs and that drinking will just move elsewhere.

“There will be more house parties, and there will be more trouble in the neighborhoods,” University of Iowa student John Chiakulas said.

The final vote on the ordinance is scheduled for April 6. It is expected that 21-only opponents will petition for a referendum to send the matter to voters this November.

A 21-only proposal was defeated by voters in 2007, with students playing a key role in that. Some opponents accused council members of ignoring the will of the voters and predicted another victory.

But 21-only had its supporters, drawing from the ranks of UI officials, parents and even some students.

“I would rather be a proud alumni of a town that supports responsibility rather than the pleasure of the current moment,” said UI student Sam Konchar.