Legislators: Say no to nuclear power bill

By Mike Carberry

------

The old saying goes that watching laws get made is like watching sausage get made. They may be good at the end but the process is pretty ugly to watch. The 2011 Iowa Legislative session is one such ugly viewing experience.

In the November 2010 election, the Republican Party took control of the Iowa House of Representatives and the Iowa governor's seat. The Democratic Party was left with a slim 26-24 majority in the Iowa Senate. This left the Democrats with a tough job of protecting the people's rights and protecting the environment from the corporations who look to gain more power and go about their polluting ways, unfettered by regulation and oversight.

The Senate Democrats have done a great job of protecting the people and the environment of Iowa until early this month when they let a nuclear power bill get through the first legislative funnel with only token resistance. Senate Study Bill 1144 (SSB114) got through a Senate Commerce subcommittee unscathed and only two senators voted against it in the full Commerce Committee. The bill (now known as SF390) went to the full Senate for debate and possible passage.

Where are the Senate Democrats when you really need them to protect us from the devastation that this bill could create?

Many smart people can disagree on the merits of nuclear power. You can debate the safety, militarization, proliferation and nuclear waste disposal issues related to nuclear power. But the one thing that can't really be debated is the cost of nuclear power. It is the most expensive way to boil water that anybody has ever thought of. The cost of these nuclear plants will be passed onto the electric ratepayers of Iowa before they are even built.

This advanced ratemaking has happened in other states, and their electric bills have skyrocketed. Our electric rates would probably go up 5 cents per kilowatt hour right away and by 10 cents/kWh by 2020 if the nukes get built. If the nukes do not get built, the utilities get to keep all the money they have collected. This puts the financial risk on the ratepayers.

This issue really needs to be debated in both the Iowa House and Senate. We need our elected officials to stand up for the residential and business electrical customers who will get left holding the bag if this bill passes. We need them to ignore the falsehoods and campaign contributions of the utilities who are promoting this bill.

We need our elected officials to say no to this nuclear bill.

Mike Carberry is director of Green State Solutions, an Iowa City-based environmental consulting firm. Comments: mike@greenstatesolutions.com