Guest Columnists

Voter ID bill ignores real problems

The Voter Integrity Act under consideration by Iowa lawmakers addresses a non-existent problem, voter impersonation, and restricts the time frame for requesting absentee ballots. The result will be longer lines on Election Day, more inconvenience for voters and preventing some voters from casting ballots. While the act contains some good provisions, it ignores real problems in the voter registration system.

The center piece of the act is the requirement for voters to prove identity at the polling place to prevent in-person voter impersonation fraud. It is possible to impersonate a voter, but examples of this are very rare. There have been no cases reported in Scott County. Other Iowa auditors tell me there have been no cases in their counties. In the past ten years we are aware of a few cases in other states out of the many millions of votes cast over that time.

The act requires voters to present certain government issued picture IDs or a previously signed voter registration card. Precinct election officials are required to examine each ID (picture or signature and address) to insure that the person offering to vote is the same as the person depicted by the ID and resides at the address in the voter roster. My staff has measured the time it takes to verify identity and residency, and found that it will take more than 30 seconds to process the average voter. Currently it takes about ten seconds to process the average voter.

Straight party voting is also eliminated. Voters will mark up to 16 choices for partisan offices instead of one. In Scott County an average of 37 percent of people voted straight party in the last four general elections. Ending straight party voting will result in longer average times to fill out a ballot.

These longer processing and voting times will mean longer lines during the high volume voting times. Currently, our average longest wait times are about twenty minutes. We can expect average longest wait times to increase significantly, probably to more than an hour.

The act limits when voters can request absentee ballots by mail to no later than ten days before an election. Currently the restriction is the Friday before an election. This restriction does not account for why people request absentee ballots, such as work assignments, caring for out of town relatives or being unable to go to a polling place due to illness or injury. Do we really want to deny ballots to people who cannot go to a polling place as they convalesce at home after surgery?

Some provisions of the act are good, such as requiring voters to include verification numbers on absentee ballot requests, or making it illegal to remove ballots from an early voting location. These provisions increase election security without unduly burdening voters. Other provisions, such as adding the veteran ID card for identification, expand voter options without sacrificing security.


But the act does not address issues identified in the voter registration system. Iowa driver’s licenses do not identify individuals who are not U.S. citizens. Other states make this distinction. We found several noncitizens registered to vote by the DOT. There are no provisions to address this issue. The act does not require checking the juror excuse list for noncitizens, although it does require cancellation of registrations for voters whose names appear on the list, whether by mistake or not. In Scott County we check this list periodically, and found that some people are on it erroneously. It would be better to require hearings for voters whose names appear on this list at which errors can be cleared up before canceling a U.S. citizen’s right to vote.

The act allows auditors to question the signatures of voters on absentee ballot requests by comparing the signatures of voters on record. However, it does not address that thousands of voters do not have signatures on record if they registered before the early 1970s or registered at the DOT when obtaining driver’s licenses or non-operator ID cards.

The best line of defense against fraud is an accurate and complete voter registration file. Unfortunately this bill ignores real problems with the registration system in pursuit of ephemeral voter impersonation.

• Roxanna Moritz, is Scott County auditor commissioner of elections and secretary to the Iowa Association of Auditors.

Give us feedback

We value your trust and work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage. If you have found an error or omission in our reporting, tell us here.

Or if you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.



Earth Day is an opportunity to reflect on the condition of our natural resources and what we're doing to protect them for the next generation. That work wouldn't be possible without great people and great partners. So, on Earth Da ...

April is the Month of the Military Child. On, April 11, I had the honor of signing a proclamation recognizing the courage and sacrifice of Iowa's military-connected youth and challenging Iowans to 'Purple Up.' Nearly 7,500 militar ...

Give us feedback

We value your trust and work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage. If you have found an error or omission in our reporting, tell us here.

Or if you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.