Big employers embrace health plan status quo

Shrinking jobless numbers encourages companies to provide coverage

The shrinking unemployment rate has been a healthy turn for people with job-based benefits.

Eager to attract help in a tight labor market and unsure of the Affordable Care Act’s future, large employers are newly committed to maintaining coverage for workers and often their families, according to new research and interviews with analysts.

Two surveys of large employers released this month — one by consultancy Willis Towers Watson and the other from the National Business Group on Health — show companies continue to try to control costs while backing away from shrinking or dropping health benefits. NBGH is a coalition of large employers.

“The extent of uncertainty in Washington has made people reluctant to make changes to their benefit programs without knowing what’s happening,” said Julie Stone, a senior benefits consultant with Willis Towers Watson. “They’re taking a wait-and-see attitude.”

That’s a marked change from three years ago, when many big employers — those with 1,000 employees or more — contemplated ending medical benefits and shifting workers to the ACA’s marketplaces.

In 2014, only 25 percent of big companies were “very confident” they would have a job-based health plan for employees in 10 years, according to the Willis Towers Watson survey.

This year, 65 percent expected to offer health benefits in a decade. And 92 percent said they were very confident a company-based health plan would exist in five years.

Many managers once eyed Obamacare marketplaces as workable coverage alternatives despite the law’s requirement that employers offer health insurance, analysts said.

But problems with marketplace plans, including fewer offerings, rising premiums and shrinking medical networks, have made employers think twice, they said.

Another big reason to maintain rich coverage is “the strength of the economy,” said Paul Fronstin, director of health research at the Employee Benefit Research Institute, an industry group. “Employers are doing what they have to do to get the right workers.”

Unemployment has fallen from 9.9 percent when Obamacare became law in 2010 to 4.3 percent last month, which equaled a 16-year low reached in May.

With such a steep decline, he added, “employers are thinking, ‘We need to offer this benefit for recruitment and retention.’”

Companies are even rethinking the long-standing expedient of shifting a portion of rising medical costs to employees through high-deductible plans and a greater share of the premium bill, other research shows.

“Employers are beginning to recognize that cost sharing has its limits,” said a June report from PwC, a multinational professional services network. Low unemployment and competition for workers mean “employers have less appetite for scaling back benefits and continuing with a plan design that has proven largely unpopular.”

At Fidelity Investments, a Boston-based financial company with more than 45,000 employees, worker contributions have grown to about 30 percent of total health costs.

Jennifer Hanson, the company’s benefits chief who sits on NBGH’s board, doesn’t see that continuing.


As costs grow, “if you continue to shift more of a bigger number to employees, health care becomes unaffordable,” she said in an interview. “As employers, we really do need to pay attention less to who’s paying for what and more to how much everything costs.”

More than half of Americans with job-based insurance face deductibles — out-of-pocket costs for most care before insurance kicks in — of more than $1,000 for single-person coverage. Family deductibles can be much higher.



Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway Inc on Saturday reported a record quarterly and annual profit, benefiting from a lower U.S. corporate income tax rate.Fourth-quarter net income increased roughly fivefold to $32.55 billion, or $ ...

The number of people who pay both to shop at Costco and to receive free, two-day shipping from Amazon has grown rapidly in the past five years.Fifty-seven percent of Costco members also pay for Amazon Prime, up from 13 percent in ...

Give us feedback

Have you found an error or omission in our reporting? Tell us here.

Do you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.