REVIEW | 'The Book of Delights'

'Delight journal' falls well short on delight

The premise behind Indiana poet and teacher Ross Gay’s first work of prose, “The Book of Delights,” is alluring. Every day or so for a year after his 42nd birthday, he will write an “essayette” on something that has given him a flash of joy — glimpses of beauty, sweet encounters with strangers, humorous moments, unexpected reprieves from boredom or pain, some sight he has eagerly twisted his head toward “like a sunflower.” (It also acknowledges many painful moments, as when Gay shares his black father’s story of how his white grandmother shook his hand only reluctantly, then wiped it on her apron, upon meeting him in 1971 in Verndale, Minn.)

This unusual and imaginative book is likely to inspire many readers to hone what Gay calls “a delight radar” and to create “delight journals” of their own. The problem is, Gay’s essays aren’t particularly delightful. For every one that’s full of grace, such as one exploring the comfortable, unspoken trust that strangers riding together in a train feel after an extended time, there’s a goofy, indulgent one, such as a three-pager on how Gay collects his own urine to use as fertilizer, and how this one time his girlfriend’s daughter grabbed a bottle of it thinking it was a soft drink. Not delightful.

In addition, the essays are packed with allusions that will send even well-read readers to Google, an exercise that gets in the way of the reader’s delight. The writing is often careless, full of long, winding sentences that appear to have been dashed off. Perhaps such spontaneity is the point, but it makes for a bit of a struggle on our part. Gay has a passion for social justice and a fine and curious eye, but his pen wanders too much into things that feel banal rather than delightful. His idea will inspire, but the execution falls short.

Give us feedback

We value your trust and work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage. If you have found an error or omission in our reporting, tell us here.

Or if you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.