Cedar Rapids, IA, USA  
Digital Edition Digital Edition
Log in Log In My Account My Account
Subscribe Today
The Gazette The Gazette
The Gazette The Gazette
  • COVID-19
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Food and Drink
  • Business
Digital Edition Digital Edition
Log in Log In My Account My Account
Subscribe
CLOSE
The Gazette
Subscribe
My Account
  • News
    • All News
    • Election 2020
    • Coronavirus
    • Business News
    • Community
    • Crime and Courts
    • Education
    • Government
    • Health
    • Nation and World
    • Time Machine
    • Search Archive

    Our Journalists

    • Rod Boshart
    • Lee Hermiston
    • Erin Jordan
    • James Q. Lynch
    • Trish Mehaffey
    • Vanessa Miller
    • Kat Russell
    • Grace King
    • John Steppe
    • Gage Miskimen
    • Marissa Payne
  • Sports
    • All Sports
    • Iowa Hawkeyes
    • Hawkeye Football
    • Hawkeye Basketball
    • Prep Sports
    • Prep Volleyball
    • Prep Football
    • Prep Basketball
    • Prep Wrestling
    • Iowa State Cyclones
    • UNI Panthers
    • Small College Sports
    • Minor League Sports
    • Outdoors

    Sports Desk

    • Mike Hlas
    • Jeff Johnson
    • Jeff Linder
    • J.R. Ogden
    • K.J. Pilcher
    • Leah Vann
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Editorial Mission
    • Guest Columnists
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Political Cartoons
    • Staff Columnists
    • Staff Editorials
    • Submit a Letter or Column

    Our Columnists

    • Todd Dorman
    • Adam Sullivan
  • Food and Drink
    • All Food and Drink
    • Chew on This
    • Recipes
    • Restaurants
  • Business
    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Business Notes
    • Companies
    • Personal Finance
    • Economy
    • Employment
    • Energy
    • Manufacturing
    • Openings & Closures
    • Real Estate
    • Retail
    • Small Business
    • Transportation

    Our Journalists

    • Rod Boshart
    • Erin Jordan
    • John Steppe
  • Obituaries
    • All Obituaries
    • In Memory Of
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Podcasts
    • All Podcasts
    • Daily News Podcast
    • Fact Checker
    • Hlastradamus Odds
    • Iowa Prep Sports
    • On Iowa
    • On Iowa Politics
    • On UNI
    • Pinning Combination
  • Entertainment
    • All Entertainment
    • Art
    • Books
    • Museums & Galleries
    • Music
    • Theater
    • Things To Do
  • Living
    • All Living
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Milestones
    • People & Places
    • Pets & Animals
    • Recreation
    • Religion & Belief
    • Travel

    Our Writers

    • Diana Nollen
    • Elijah Decious
  • Kids Gazette
    • See All
    • Kids Cooking Series
    • Kids Galleries
    • Printables
    • Activities
    • Articles
    • Submissions
    • Resources
  • Photos
    • All Photos and Videos
    • The Iowa Photo
    • Photo Store

    Our Photojournalists

    • Andy Abeyta
    • Liz Martin
    • Rebecca Miller
    • Jim Slosiarek
    • Gazette Visuals
  • Milestones
    • All Milestones
    • Anniversaries
    • Days To Remember
    • Engagements
    • Holidays
    • In Remembrance
    • New Arrivals
    • Thank Yous
    • Submit a Milestone
  • Data
    • Arrests
    • Building Permits
    • Interactive Maps & Charts
    • Salaries
  • Gazette Sites
    • Classifieds
    • Corridor Careers
    • Garage Sales
    • Gazette Gives Back
    • Gazette Rewards
    • Gazette Store
    • Green Gazette
    • HER
    • Iowa Wedding Experience
    • Holiday Light Finder
    • Hoopla
    • Iowa Ideas
    • Photo Store
  • Special Events
  • Special Sections
  • Other
    • About The Gazette
    • Archives
    • Article Removal
    • Business Directory
    • CR Arrest Database
    • Mobile Apps
    • Customer Care
    • Order Back Issues
    • Privacy Policies
    • Puzzle Answers
    • Sponsorship Requests
    • Submit a Letter
    • Weather
  • Digital Edition
Daily News PodcastDaily News Podcast
Daily NewslettersDaily Newsletters
Log out

FOLLOW US

The Gazette
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Food and Drink
  • Business
  • Obituaries
  • Podcasts
  • Entertainment
  • Living
  • Kids Gazette
  • Photos
  • Milestones
  • Data
  • Gazette Sites
  • Special Events
  • Special Sections
  • Other
  • Digital Edition
  • All News
  • Election 2020
  • Coronavirus
  • Business News
  • Community
  • Crime and Courts
  • Education
  • Government
  • Health
  • Nation and World
  • Time Machine
  • Search Archive

Our Journalists

  • Rod Boshart
  • Lee Hermiston
  • Erin Jordan
  • James Q. Lynch
  • Trish Mehaffey
  • Vanessa Miller
  • Kat Russell
  • Grace King
  • John Steppe
  • Gage Miskimen
  • Marissa Payne
  • All Sports
  • Iowa Hawkeyes
  • Hawkeye Football
  • Hawkeye Basketball
  • Prep Sports
  • Prep Volleyball
  • Prep Football
  • Prep Basketball
  • Prep Wrestling
  • Iowa State Cyclones
  • UNI Panthers
  • Small College Sports
  • Minor League Sports
  • Outdoors

Sports Desk

  • Mike Hlas
  • Jeff Johnson
  • Jeff Linder
  • J.R. Ogden
  • K.J. Pilcher
  • Leah Vann
  • All Opinion
  • Editorial Mission
  • Guest Columnists
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Political Cartoons
  • Staff Columnists
  • Staff Editorials
  • Submit a Letter or Column

Our Columnists

  • Todd Dorman
  • Adam Sullivan
  • All Food and Drink
  • Chew on This
  • Recipes
  • Restaurants
  • All Business
  • Agriculture
  • Business Notes
  • Companies
  • Personal Finance
  • Economy
  • Employment
  • Energy
  • Manufacturing
  • Openings & Closures
  • Real Estate
  • Retail
  • Small Business
  • Transportation

Our Journalists

  • Rod Boshart
  • Erin Jordan
  • John Steppe
  • All Obituaries
  • In Memory Of
  • Submit an Obituary
  • All Podcasts
  • Daily News Podcast
  • Fact Checker
  • Hlastradamus Odds
  • Iowa Prep Sports
  • On Iowa
  • On Iowa Politics
  • On UNI
  • Pinning Combination
  • All Entertainment
  • Art
  • Books
  • Museums & Galleries
  • Music
  • Theater
  • Things To Do
  • All Living
  • Health & Wellness
  • Home & Garden
  • Milestones
  • People & Places
  • Pets & Animals
  • Recreation
  • Religion & Belief
  • Travel

Our Writers

  • Diana Nollen
  • Elijah Decious
  • See All
  • Kids Cooking Series
  • Kids Galleries
  • Printables
  • Activities
  • Articles
  • Submissions
  • Resources
  • All Photos and Videos
  • The Iowa Photo
  • Photo Store

Our Photojournalists

  • Andy Abeyta
  • Liz Martin
  • Rebecca Miller
  • Jim Slosiarek
  • Gazette Visuals
  • All Milestones
  • Anniversaries
  • Days To Remember
  • Engagements
  • Holidays
  • In Remembrance
  • New Arrivals
  • Thank Yous
  • Submit a Milestone
  • Arrests
  • Building Permits
  • Interactive Maps & Charts
  • Salaries
  • Classifieds
  • Corridor Careers
  • Garage Sales
  • Gazette Gives Back
  • Gazette Rewards
  • Gazette Store
  • Green Gazette
  • HER
  • Iowa Wedding Experience
  • Holiday Light Finder
  • Hoopla
  • Iowa Ideas
  • Photo Store
  • About The Gazette
  • Archives
  • Article Removal
  • Business Directory
  • CR Arrest Database
  • Mobile Apps
  • Customer Care
  • Order Back Issues
  • Privacy Policies
  • Puzzle Answers
  • Sponsorship Requests
  • Submit a Letter
  • Weather
Daily News PodcastDaily News Podcast Daily NewslettersDaily Newsletters
LOG OUT

FOLLOW US

More Stories

Brucemore celebrates 40 years of being open to the public

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

Meet the Iowan behind the Vaccine Hunter website

Wellington Heights home gutted in 2017 fire finally coming down

26-year-old man killed in shooting in NE Cedar Rapids

Peggy Whitson to be keynote speaker for Iowa Ideas 2021

Here’s how to get rid of your derecho tree debris

Livestream: Funeral for Iowa state trooper Jim Smith

Home / News / Education

University of Iowa hires consultants without competitive bidding

Vanessa MillerBy: Vanessa Miller Mar. 1, 2019 11:00 pm Updated: Mar. 1, 2019 11:12 pm
University of Iowa hires consultants without competitive biddingUniversity of Iowa hires consultants without competitive biddingUniversity of Iowa hires consultants without competitive biddingUniversity of Iowa hires consultants without competitive biddingUniversity of Iowa hires consultants without competitive bidding

In hiring consultants for its inquiry into monetizing its utilities operation, the University of Iowa skirted standard purchasing policies set by the state, Board of Regents and the UI - citing the project's 'unique and unusual” nature.

In October, November and January, the UI committed to or contracted with a law office, investment adviser and engineering firm - without soliciting bids - to help evaluate UI assets, identify possible partners and map out a plan for a potential public-private partnership.

A potential partnership, which the university recently started investigating, would allow an outside company to take over the UI power operation for 50 years - and receive annual UI payments for doing so - in exchange for a hefty upfront sum the university could put into an endowment supporting academics.

The university would maintain ownership of its system and require any operator sustain quality standards and sustainability efforts. The operator would benefit in that a deal would guarantee it 50 years of reliable revenue, with tax benefits the university isn't privy to.

legal services exempt, UI says

Although UI officials have left open the prospective value of any partner's upfront payment - which would go into an endowment that annually would support the UI's 'core missions” - Ohio State University privatized its utilities by securing an upfront payment of $1.015 billion.

UI officials have noted Iowa is half the size of Ohio State and, for that reason, likely wouldn't get as much. But, because Ohio State was among the first universities to attempt such a deal, UI officials in October engaged the law firm it worked with - Chicago-based Jones Day - to 'provide advice to the university regarding the possibility of monetizing certain of its energy assets.”

An Oct. 15 engagement letter for what is expected to be a monthslong, if not yearslong, process outlines payment for Jones Day services at $800 to $1,500 an hour for partners and $450 to $800 for associates.

State, regents and UI policies require competitive bidding for the purchase of all goods and services greater than $50,000, but UI officials told The Gazette that legal services are excluded and must only be approved by the Board of Regents' office.

'The university provided the Jones Day engagement letter for review to the board office, and its legal counsel provided verbal confirmation,” according to UI spokeswoman Anne Bassett. 'This is the UI's typical process for retaining outside counsel.”

Jones Day gave the UI names of financial firms experienced in public-private transactions, and the university conducted phone interviews with Barclays, Morgan Stanley and Wells Fargo Securities LLC, Bassett said.

Another exception to bidding policies

The university on Nov. 28 signed a contract through June 30, 2020, with Wells Fargo to pay it a cut of the value of any monetization transaction - meaning it could make millions - to, among other things, assess UI assets, propose a potential transaction value, identify potential partners, and close and complete a deal.

In choosing the three finalists and, ultimately, Wells Fargo for the job, the university did not issue any request for qualifications, quotations or proposals, as is required by UI, board and state policies. Instead, in early November, UI Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer Terry Johnson produced a 'sole source justification” for the Wells Fargo selection.

'President (Bruce) Harreld and (Board of Regents Executive Director) Mark Braun support this recommendation,” Johnson wrote in a Nov. 9 email to an associate vice president.

The UI's procurement policy lets it waive competitive bidding requirements for a variety of reasons, including if 'there is only one person or firm that can provide the requirement.” The sole-source exception mandates 'no other known person or firm is available with an equivalent service or supply.”

The sole-source document justifying the Wells Fargo selection without competitive bidding notes Jones Day recommended three financial services firms 'with the experience and expertise required for this type of complex financial transaction.”

'All recommended firms have significant experience negotiating (public-private partnership) higher education deals,” according to the sole-source justification.

The university's rationale for choosing Wells Fargo, as reported in its sole-source justification, highlighted the company's willingness to consider a tiered fee structure, its work representing the buyer in the Ohio State energy deal, a recommendation from Ohio State and a strong telephone interview.

In response to questions from The Gazette about how Wells Fargo qualified for a sole-source justification when it was among at least three firms recommended for the job, UI Senior Vice President Rod Lehnertz said the sole-source policy is written 'primarily for material purchasing or capital project work.”

'And this is neither,” he said in an emailed response. 'Every situation is unique and in unusual cases, like this (public-private partnership), we research and then interview best practice experts and then, even after considering more than one, because it is not typical, we communicate our efforts to the (Board of Regents) office and confirm their support/approval.”

Lehnertz added the university took an 'extra step by interviewing and considering three potentially viable firms and then we requested a sole-source approval for the one that was most qualified.”

No public bid for engineering firm

With both Jones Day and Wells Fargo on board, the consultants recommended to UI four engineering firms for the job of developing an inventory report and high-level assessment of its central steam, chilled water, electrical and water treatment systems.

The university - using an 'informal request for qualifications process” that did not involve public bidding - interviewed three of the four recommended firms, choosing Jacobs Engineering 'due to its breadth of experience within the energy sector.”

Jacobs on Jan. 10 provided the university a 'letter of interest for public-private partnership technical advisory services” and a detailed proposal specific to the UI project.

In that letter, a Jacobs executive reports, 'We are excited to be considered as your technical adviser for this public-private partnership opportunity.”

In its 25-page proposal, the firm highlighted its successful track record and depth of experience, and promised a technical risk assessment and condition assessment report.

The university on Jan. 23 signed a one-year contract with Jacobs Engineering to pay it a lump sum of $185,000, not including expenses for consultants or potential upcharges for services outside the initial scope - with hourly rates ranging from $95 to $355.

The university did not provide details about the 'informal request for qualifications process” it cited in hiring Jacobs Engineering.

'Each of the consulting firms engaged by the UI on this project are industry leaders in their respective fields and engaged to help the university through its exploration of the public-private partnership process,” Bassett said in an email.

Regents praise UI for plan, transparency

A preliminary timeline for the UI public-private partnership exploration involves public information sessions March 5 on the west side of campus and March 6 on the east side. Administrators already have held informational sessions with staff and faculty, some of whom aired concerns.

The tentative timeline has the university issuing a request for qualifications in April and a request for proposals in June, in hopes of choosing a vendor in the coming fall semester and signing an agreement before the end of the year.

UI officials have said they're considering this collaboration in response to the state's disinvestment in public higher education that's translated recently to midyear cuts and de-appropriations.

Earlier this week, during a regents meeting, Board President Mike Richards praised the UI for exploring the alternative revenue source and being transparent in the process.

'We will need additional resources in the future, and exploring ways to find new sources of revenue to add to our existing ones is helpful to all parties,” Richards said. 'That should be encouraged and applauded.”

He specifically commended Harreld and his team for being deliberative and forward-thinking.

'They are also are being transparent about the process - having open discussions with a wide variety of constituents,” Richards said.

If the UI venture proves successful, Richards said, the board's other public universities might consider following suit.

'We have a lot of good indications it's going to be a really positive thing,” he said. 'And I'm sure that if it works out really well, we're going to encourage the other universities to look at similar projects.”

l Comments: (319) 339-3158; vanessa.miller@thegazette.com

Steam rises from the University of Iowa Power Plant in Iowa City on Friday, Feb. 8, 2019. (Liz Martin/The Gazette)
Turbine generators at the University of Iowa Power Plant in Iowa City on Friday, Feb. 8, 2019. (Liz Martin/The Gazette)
Three turbine generators at the University of Iowa Power Plant in Iowa City on Friday, Feb. 8, 2019. (Liz Martin/The Gazette)
Steam rises from the University of Iowa Power Plant in Iowa City on Friday, Feb. 8, 2019. (Liz Martin/The Gazette)
Steam rises from the University of Iowa Power Plant in Iowa City on Friday, Feb. 8, 2019. (Liz Martin/The Gazette)
In Depth / Enterprise, University of Iowa, Iowa City
Vanessa Miller

Vanessa Miller

Reporter, The Gazette

Higher education reporter for The Gazette in Eastern Iowa. I love news tips, story ideas and reader feedback.

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

UI bookstore changes strip alternative book vendors from website

2nd University of Iowa presidential finalist touts visibility, diversity, communication

Grinnell College mandating COVID vaccines

CFO: University of Iowa hospitals doing better than most post-COVID

All articles by Vanessa

Give us feedback

We work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage because we value your trust. If you find an error or omission in our reporting, please tell us here.

Submit a story idea

Do you have a story idea that we should look into? Please tell us here.

Related Stories

Internet opens Iowa’s sports betting floodgate

Internet opens Iowa’s sports betting floodgate

Rod Boshart Government & Politics Apr. 4, 2021 11:55 am

RV sales soar ahead of pandemic’s second summer

RV sales soar ahead of pandemic’s second summer

Tom Barton, Quad-City Times Business News Apr. 1, 2021 11:07 pm

Magnet for danger, Cedar Rapids house alarms neighbors

Magnet for danger, Cedar Rapids house alarms neighbors

Trish Mehaffey Crime and Courts Mar. 24, 2021 6:26 pm

Education

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed 3h ago

UI bookstore changes strip alternative book vendors from website

UI bookstore changes strip alternative book vendors from website

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed Apr. 16, 2021 10:07 am

Peggy Whitson to be keynote speaker for Iowa Ideas 2021

Peggy Whitson to be keynote speaker for Iowa Ideas 2021

Grace King

Apr. 15, 2021 2:15 pm

2nd University of Iowa presidential finalist touts visibility, diversity, communication

2nd University of Iowa presidential finalist touts visibility, diversity, communication

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed Apr. 15, 2021 7:58 pm

News

100 bills in Hinson’s first 100 days in House

100 bills in Hinson’s first 100 days in House

James Q. Lynch

Government & Politics 26m ago

More than 2 million vaccine doses have been administered in…

More than 2 million vaccine doses have been administered in…

Kat Russell

Health Care and Medicine 36m ago

NewBoCo to offer zero-interest loans to minority-owned businesses

NewBoCo to offer zero-interest loans to minority-owned businesses

John Steppe

Small Business News 3h ago

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed 3h ago

Policy

Iowa House passes bill to expand charter schools after lengthy…

Iowa House passes bill to expand charter schools after lengthy…

James Q. Lynch

Government & Politics Mar. 25, 2021 8:39 am

Iowa regents create permanent free speech committee, expect more changes

Iowa regents create permanent free speech committee, expect more changes

Vanessa Miller

Education Feb. 24, 2021 11:22 pm

Bill would require parents to ‘opt in’ for kids to…

Bill would require parents to ‘opt in’ for kids to…

Rod Boshart

Government & Politics Feb. 16, 2021 4:35 pm

College Community superintendent says ‘no’ to school vouchers

College Community superintendent says ‘no’ to school vouchers

Grace King

Education Feb. 12, 2021 7:59 am

Higher Education

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed 3h ago

UI bookstore changes strip alternative book vendors from website

UI bookstore changes strip alternative book vendors from website

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed Apr. 16, 2021 10:07 am

Grinnell College mandating COVID vaccines

Grinnell College mandating COVID vaccines

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed Apr. 15, 2021 4:41 pm

CFO: University of Iowa hospitals doing better than most post-COVID

CFO: University of Iowa hospitals doing better than most post-COVID

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed Apr. 14, 2021 8:01 pm

FOLLOW US

The Gazette is Iowa’s independent, employee-owned source for local, state, and national news coverage.

© 2021 The Gazette

All Rights Reserved.

  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy
  • Web Accessibility

Contact Us

  • 116 3rd St SE
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52401
  • customercare@thegazette.com
  • (319) 398-8333
  • Live Chat

Links

  • Puzzle Answers
  • CR Arrest Database
  • Article Removal Request
  • Gazette Archives
  • Green Gazette
  • Corridor Careers Jobs
  • Work at The Gazette
  • Customer Care

© 2021 The Gazette

All Rights Reserved.

  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy
  • Web Accessibility
Folience A Folience Company