Cedar Rapids, IA, USA  
Digital Edition Digital Edition
Log in Log In My Account My Account
Subscribe Today
The Gazette The Gazette
The Gazette The Gazette
  • COVID-19
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Food and Drink
  • Business
Digital Edition Digital Edition
Log in Log In My Account My Account
Subscribe
CLOSE
The Gazette
Subscribe
My Account
  • News
    • All News
    • Election 2020
    • Coronavirus
    • Business News
    • Community
    • Crime and Courts
    • Education
    • Government
    • Health
    • Nation and World
    • Time Machine
    • Search Archive

    Our Journalists

    • Rod Boshart
    • Lee Hermiston
    • Erin Jordan
    • James Q. Lynch
    • Trish Mehaffey
    • Vanessa Miller
    • Kat Russell
    • Grace King
    • John Steppe
    • Gage Miskimen
    • Marissa Payne
  • Sports
    • All Sports
    • Iowa Hawkeyes
    • Hawkeye Football
    • Hawkeye Basketball
    • Prep Sports
    • Prep Volleyball
    • Prep Football
    • Prep Basketball
    • Prep Wrestling
    • Iowa State Cyclones
    • UNI Panthers
    • Small College Sports
    • Minor League Sports
    • Outdoors

    Sports Desk

    • Mike Hlas
    • Jeff Johnson
    • Jeff Linder
    • J.R. Ogden
    • K.J. Pilcher
    • Leah Vann
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Editorial Mission
    • Guest Columnists
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Political Cartoons
    • Staff Columnists
    • Staff Editorials
    • Submit a Letter or Column

    Our Columnists

    • Todd Dorman
    • Adam Sullivan
  • Food and Drink
    • All Food and Drink
    • Chew on This
    • Recipes
    • Restaurants
  • Business
    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Business Notes
    • Companies
    • Personal Finance
    • Economy
    • Employment
    • Energy
    • Manufacturing
    • Openings & Closures
    • Real Estate
    • Retail
    • Small Business
    • Transportation

    Our Journalists

    • Rod Boshart
    • Erin Jordan
    • John Steppe
  • Obituaries
    • All Obituaries
    • In Memory Of
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Podcasts
    • All Podcasts
    • Daily News Podcast
    • Fact Checker
    • Hlastradamus Odds
    • Iowa Prep Sports
    • On Iowa
    • On Iowa Politics
    • On UNI
    • Pinning Combination
  • Entertainment
    • All Entertainment
    • Art
    • Books
    • Museums & Galleries
    • Music
    • Theater
    • Things To Do
  • Living
    • All Living
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Milestones
    • People & Places
    • Pets & Animals
    • Recreation
    • Religion & Belief
    • Travel

    Our Writers

    • Diana Nollen
    • Elijah Decious
  • Kids Gazette
    • See All
    • Kids Cooking Series
    • Kids Galleries
    • Printables
    • Activities
    • Articles
    • Submissions
    • Resources
  • Photos
    • All Photos and Videos
    • The Iowa Photo
    • Photo Store

    Our Photojournalists

    • Andy Abeyta
    • Liz Martin
    • Rebecca Miller
    • Jim Slosiarek
    • Gazette Visuals
  • Milestones
    • All Milestones
    • Anniversaries
    • Days To Remember
    • Engagements
    • Holidays
    • In Remembrance
    • New Arrivals
    • Thank Yous
    • Submit a Milestone
  • Data
    • Arrests
    • Building Permits
    • Interactive Maps & Charts
    • Salaries
  • Gazette Sites
    • Classifieds
    • Corridor Careers
    • Garage Sales
    • Gazette Gives Back
    • Gazette Rewards
    • Gazette Store
    • Green Gazette
    • HER
    • Iowa Wedding Experience
    • Holiday Light Finder
    • Hoopla
    • Iowa Ideas
    • Photo Store
  • Special Events
  • Special Sections
  • Other
    • About The Gazette
    • Archives
    • Article Removal
    • Business Directory
    • CR Arrest Database
    • Mobile Apps
    • Customer Care
    • Order Back Issues
    • Privacy Policies
    • Puzzle Answers
    • Sponsorship Requests
    • Submit a Letter
    • Weather
  • Digital Edition
Daily News PodcastDaily News Podcast
Daily NewslettersDaily Newsletters
Log out

FOLLOW US

The Gazette
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Food and Drink
  • Business
  • Obituaries
  • Podcasts
  • Entertainment
  • Living
  • Kids Gazette
  • Photos
  • Milestones
  • Data
  • Gazette Sites
  • Special Events
  • Special Sections
  • Other
  • Digital Edition
  • All News
  • Election 2020
  • Coronavirus
  • Business News
  • Community
  • Crime and Courts
  • Education
  • Government
  • Health
  • Nation and World
  • Time Machine
  • Search Archive

Our Journalists

  • Rod Boshart
  • Lee Hermiston
  • Erin Jordan
  • James Q. Lynch
  • Trish Mehaffey
  • Vanessa Miller
  • Kat Russell
  • Grace King
  • John Steppe
  • Gage Miskimen
  • Marissa Payne
  • All Sports
  • Iowa Hawkeyes
  • Hawkeye Football
  • Hawkeye Basketball
  • Prep Sports
  • Prep Volleyball
  • Prep Football
  • Prep Basketball
  • Prep Wrestling
  • Iowa State Cyclones
  • UNI Panthers
  • Small College Sports
  • Minor League Sports
  • Outdoors

Sports Desk

  • Mike Hlas
  • Jeff Johnson
  • Jeff Linder
  • J.R. Ogden
  • K.J. Pilcher
  • Leah Vann
  • All Opinion
  • Editorial Mission
  • Guest Columnists
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Political Cartoons
  • Staff Columnists
  • Staff Editorials
  • Submit a Letter or Column

Our Columnists

  • Todd Dorman
  • Adam Sullivan
  • All Food and Drink
  • Chew on This
  • Recipes
  • Restaurants
  • All Business
  • Agriculture
  • Business Notes
  • Companies
  • Personal Finance
  • Economy
  • Employment
  • Energy
  • Manufacturing
  • Openings & Closures
  • Real Estate
  • Retail
  • Small Business
  • Transportation

Our Journalists

  • Rod Boshart
  • Erin Jordan
  • John Steppe
  • All Obituaries
  • In Memory Of
  • Submit an Obituary
  • All Podcasts
  • Daily News Podcast
  • Fact Checker
  • Hlastradamus Odds
  • Iowa Prep Sports
  • On Iowa
  • On Iowa Politics
  • On UNI
  • Pinning Combination
  • All Entertainment
  • Art
  • Books
  • Museums & Galleries
  • Music
  • Theater
  • Things To Do
  • All Living
  • Health & Wellness
  • Home & Garden
  • Milestones
  • People & Places
  • Pets & Animals
  • Recreation
  • Religion & Belief
  • Travel

Our Writers

  • Diana Nollen
  • Elijah Decious
  • See All
  • Kids Cooking Series
  • Kids Galleries
  • Printables
  • Activities
  • Articles
  • Submissions
  • Resources
  • All Photos and Videos
  • The Iowa Photo
  • Photo Store

Our Photojournalists

  • Andy Abeyta
  • Liz Martin
  • Rebecca Miller
  • Jim Slosiarek
  • Gazette Visuals
  • All Milestones
  • Anniversaries
  • Days To Remember
  • Engagements
  • Holidays
  • In Remembrance
  • New Arrivals
  • Thank Yous
  • Submit a Milestone
  • Arrests
  • Building Permits
  • Interactive Maps & Charts
  • Salaries
  • Classifieds
  • Corridor Careers
  • Garage Sales
  • Gazette Gives Back
  • Gazette Rewards
  • Gazette Store
  • Green Gazette
  • HER
  • Iowa Wedding Experience
  • Holiday Light Finder
  • Hoopla
  • Iowa Ideas
  • Photo Store
  • About The Gazette
  • Archives
  • Article Removal
  • Business Directory
  • CR Arrest Database
  • Mobile Apps
  • Customer Care
  • Order Back Issues
  • Privacy Policies
  • Puzzle Answers
  • Sponsorship Requests
  • Submit a Letter
  • Weather
Daily News PodcastDaily News Podcast Daily NewslettersDaily Newsletters
LOG OUT

FOLLOW US

More Stories

Iowa lawmaker: ’We’re looking for a lifetime of justice’

Black Lives Matter advocates ’in tears’ after guilty verdicts in…

How to improve Iowa’s bottle bill? Raise handling fee, allow…

CJ Fredrick transferring stings Iowa, but college sports will survive…

Woman testifies former lover killed man over meth quality

150 additional Drake Relays tickets inside stadium will go on…

Nearly half of Iowa’s counties decline new COVID-19 vaccine doses

University of Iowa among hospitals suing feds over organ-donation changes

Home / News / Education

Religious freedom fight still taking on University of Iowa

Vanessa MillerBy: Vanessa Miller Sep. 24, 2020 8:38 pm Updated: Sep. 24, 2020 8:38 pm
Religious freedom fight still taking on University of Iowa

IOWA CITY - A faith-based group at the University of Iowa stripped three years ago of its student organization status for barring a gay member from becoming a leader isn't looking for a windfall in court.

But it is looking to make a point - years after it went to court against the UI and later won some - but not all - of its religious freedom lawsuit and was allowed back on campus.

The student group's Washington, D.C.-based attorneys talked about that message earlier this week in arguments before a panel of three federal appellate judges.

'The Supreme Court cases on religious discrimination are clear on this issue. And so is this court … I would add that the free speech law is also exceedingly clear,” Eric Baxter - vice president and senior counsel at Becket Law, which has represented the UI student group Business Leaders in Christ since it was deregistered in late 2017 - said before the U.S. Court of Appeals. 'You cannot engage in viewpoint discrimination just because you have a non-discrimination policy.”

A federal judge had seemingly decided this dispute in February 2019 with a split ruling on some of the 20 allegations against the UI - favoring the group on several, the university on others and leaving 13 claims unresolved, which attorneys agreed to drop.

But the student group - which goes by BLinC - wouldn't drop one of the issues that the judge found in favor of the UI and its three individual co-defendants: Lyn Redington, UI dean of students at the time; Thomas Baker, assistant dean of students at the time; and William Nelson, executive director of the Iowa Memorial Union.

Deciding that 'the law was not clearly established,” the judge gave Redington, Baker and Nelson 'qualified immunity” - which shields government officials from lawsuits unless attorneys can show violation of clearly established laws or rights that any reasonable person would have known.

Becket appealed in May 2019, saying the individuals should not have qualified immunity.

'Defendants had extensive relevant experience enforcing First Amendment principles on campus and expressly admitted targeting BLinC because of its beliefs,” its attorneys said.

'This is not a ‘close case,'” Becket continued in its appeal. 'The law is clearly established that a state university may not target religious beliefs it abhors, discriminate against religious viewpoints, or entangle itself in internal religious affairs.”

Attorneys got the chance to argue their sides earlier this week before the U.S. Court of Appeals, which has taken the case under consideration and has not yet issued a ruling.

In an interview with The Gazette, Baxter said his client - which remains a UI student group within the Tippie College of Business - isn't seeking a big payout.

'We're only asking for $1,” he said. 'We're trying to send a message that this kind of discrimination is unlawful.”

The crux of BLinC's argument is that UI administrators targeted it by deregistering it for views it found unsavory after a gay student complained about being barred from BLinC's leadership ranks because of his sexual orientation.

The student organization said it requires its leaders to agree with the group's beliefs and pointed to other student groups on campus with constitutions that also specified who can and can't be a leader - like a Muslim organization and a gay-affirming Christian group.

That fact prompted the UI to engage in a sweeping review of its more than 500 student organizations, which turned up dozens of violations and more deregistrations - spawning another lawsuit from InterVarsity Graduate Christian Fellowship.

In her order, the federal judge mandated the UI allow BLinC back in good standing on campus unless it treats every student group the same - but found the issue convoluted enough to spare the individual defendants from liability.

Baxter this week said the administrators should have known better - citing decisions and instructions past UI administrators made as early as 1999 regarding the campus' Christian Legal Society and its requirement that both leaders and members embrace traditional Christian believes, including those prohibiting 'adultery, premarital sex … and homosexual conduct.”

Even when the UI student senate and later its student government refused recognition and denied the group funding, expressing discomfort with the organization, UI administrators affirmed that the constitution required funding requests be processed 'in a content neutral manner” and 'without any consideration of the organization's viewpoint,” according to legal and supporting documents.

UI officials in 2008 further warned student leaders that they're agents of the state and could be 'subject to personal liability.”

An appellate court judge this week pressed attorneys representing the UI that point: that administrators for years had recited the prohibition against student organization viewpoint discrimination.

'Generally, I don't think qualified immunity protects those who knowingly and intentionally violate constitutional rights,” the judge said. 'So I'm wondering what your views are on the district court's finding on that issue?”

Iowa Solicitor General Jeffrey Thompson, representing the UI, argued the convergence of First Amendment and human rights isn't clear-cut.

'Mr. Baxter and the court referred in part to records that dealt with memos that go back into the ‘90s and the early 2000s,” Thompson said. 'The law in Iowa, the civil rights law in Iowa, was amended in 2007. The Varnum decision about (same-sex) marriage came down in 2009. And so the relationship between the human rights policy issue and the First Amendment issue was evolving, was changing.”

BLinC's Baxter said he does not know when to expect a ruling, that it could be weeks or months.

Comments: (319) 339-3158; vanessa.miller@thegazette.com

Lawyer Eric Baxter, right, with Becket Law, attends a Jan. 19, 2018, hearing in U.S. District Court in Davenport. With him were Jake Estell and Brett Eikenberry, leaders of the University of Iowa student group Business Leaders in Christ. (Vanessa Miller/The Gazette)
Daily Report, University of Iowa, Iowa City
Vanessa Miller

Vanessa Miller

Reporter, The Gazette

Higher education reporter for The Gazette in Eastern Iowa. I love news tips, story ideas and reader feedback.

University of Iowa among hospitals suing feds over organ-donation changes

3rd University of Iowa presidential finalist vows to tackle diversity,…

University of Iowa 3rd presidential finalist: Georgia State Provost Wendy…

Michael Richards, reappointed to the Board of Regents

IMU COVID vaccine clinic coming

All articles by Vanessa

Give us feedback

We work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage because we value your trust. If you find an error or omission in our reporting, please tell us here.

Submit a story idea

Do you have a story idea that we should look into? Please tell us here.

Related Stories

Iowa adds 549 virus cases, seven deaths

Iowa adds 549 virus cases, seven deaths

Gage Miskimen Health Care and Medicine Apr. 20, 2021 5:16 pm

Iowa adds 168 virus cases, five newly reported deaths

Iowa adds 168 virus cases, five newly reported deaths

Gage Miskimen Health Care and Medicine Apr. 19, 2021 3:47 pm

800,000 Iowans vaccinated so far

800,000 Iowans vaccinated so far

Gage Miskimen Health Care and Medicine Apr. 15, 2021 2:55 pm

Education

University of Iowa among hospitals suing feds over organ-donation changes

University of Iowa among hospitals suing feds over organ-donation changes

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed Apr. 20, 2021 8:29 pm

Students invited to ’plant their dreams’ and an apple tree

Students invited to ’plant their dreams’ and an apple tree

Grace King

K-12 Education Apr. 16, 2021 5:30 pm

3rd University of Iowa presidential finalist vows to tackle diversity,…

3rd University of Iowa presidential finalist vows to tackle diversity,…

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed Apr. 20, 2021 10:41 am

100 beds built by Cedar Rapids students with Sleep in…

100 beds built by Cedar Rapids students with Sleep in…

Grace King

K-12 Education Apr. 18, 2021 7:50 pm

News

Nearly half of Iowa’s counties decline new COVID-19 vaccine doses

Nearly half of Iowa’s counties decline new COVID-19 vaccine doses

AP

News Apr. 20, 2021 6:35 pm

Chauvin guilty on all counts in George Floyd killing

Chauvin guilty on all counts in George Floyd killing

AP

News Apr. 20, 2021 4:20 pm

Watch Live: Derek Chauvin verdict is in

Watch Live: Derek Chauvin verdict is in

Stephen Schmidt

News Apr. 20, 2021 4:03 pm

Johnson County Food Policy Council forum takes place online Saturday

Johnson County Food Policy Council forum takes place online Saturday

Community Apr. 20, 2021 1:57 pm

Government & Politics

Iowa Legislature approves end of schools’ voluntary diversity programs

Iowa Legislature approves end of schools’ voluntary diversity programs

James Q. Lynch

State Government Apr. 20, 2021 6:57 pm

U.S. Rep. Cindy Axne, Iowa Democrats ask feds to investigate…

U.S. Rep. Cindy Axne, Iowa Democrats ask feds to investigate…

Erin Jordan

State Government Apr. 20, 2021 2:49 pm

Matthew 25 launches $1M campaign to revitalize Time Check

Matthew 25 launches $1M campaign to revitalize Time Check

Marissa Payne

News Apr. 19, 2021 9:42 pm

Tamara Marcus to run for District 3 City Council seat

Tamara Marcus to run for District 3 City Council seat

Marissa Payne

News Apr. 19, 2021 9:46 pm

Sports

Xavier boys’ soccer on a mission in 2021

Xavier boys’ soccer on a mission in 2021

Nathan Ford

High School Soccer Apr. 20, 2021 10:22 pm

Photos: Xavier vs. Washington boys’ soccer

Photos: Xavier vs. Washington boys’ soccer

Jim Slosiarek

4h ago

Sydney Albaugh leads power-packed Kirkwood softball lineup

Sydney Albaugh leads power-packed Kirkwood softball lineup

K.J. Pilcher

Sports 4h ago

Iowa basketball recruit Riley Mulvey is big guy from big…

Iowa basketball recruit Riley Mulvey is big guy from big…

Mike Hlas

Hawkeye Basketball Apr. 20, 2021 3:32 pm

FOLLOW US

The Gazette is Iowa’s independent, employee-owned source for local, state, and national news coverage.

© 2021 The Gazette

All Rights Reserved.

  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy
  • Web Accessibility

Contact Us

  • 116 3rd St SE
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52401
  • customercare@thegazette.com
  • (319) 398-8333
  • Live Chat

Links

  • Puzzle Answers
  • CR Arrest Database
  • Article Removal Request
  • Gazette Archives
  • Green Gazette
  • Corridor Careers Jobs
  • Work at The Gazette
  • Customer Care

© 2021 The Gazette

All Rights Reserved.

  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy
  • Web Accessibility
Folience A Folience Company