Cedar Rapids, IA, USA  
Digital Edition Digital Edition
Log in Log In My Account My Account
Subscribe Today
The Gazette The Gazette
The Gazette The Gazette
  • COVID-19
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Food and Drink
  • Business
Digital Edition Digital Edition
Log in Log In My Account My Account
Subscribe
CLOSE
The Gazette
Subscribe
My Account
  • News
    • All News
    • Election 2020
    • Coronavirus
    • Business News
    • Community
    • Crime and Courts
    • Education
    • Government
    • Health
    • Nation and World
    • Time Machine
    • Search Archive

    Our Journalists

    • Rod Boshart
    • Lee Hermiston
    • Erin Jordan
    • James Q. Lynch
    • Trish Mehaffey
    • Vanessa Miller
    • Kat Russell
    • Grace King
    • John Steppe
    • Gage Miskimen
    • Marissa Payne
  • Sports
    • All Sports
    • Iowa Hawkeyes
    • Hawkeye Football
    • Hawkeye Basketball
    • Prep Sports
    • Prep Volleyball
    • Prep Football
    • Prep Basketball
    • Prep Wrestling
    • Iowa State Cyclones
    • UNI Panthers
    • Small College Sports
    • Minor League Sports
    • Outdoors

    Sports Desk

    • Mike Hlas
    • Jeff Johnson
    • Jeff Linder
    • J.R. Ogden
    • K.J. Pilcher
    • Leah Vann
  • Opinion
    • All Opinion
    • Editorial Mission
    • Guest Columnists
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Political Cartoons
    • Staff Columnists
    • Staff Editorials
    • Submit a Letter or Column

    Our Columnists

    • Todd Dorman
    • Adam Sullivan
  • Food and Drink
    • All Food and Drink
    • Chew on This
    • Recipes
    • Restaurants
  • Business
    • All Business
    • Agriculture
    • Business Notes
    • Companies
    • Personal Finance
    • Economy
    • Employment
    • Energy
    • Manufacturing
    • Openings & Closures
    • Real Estate
    • Retail
    • Small Business
    • Transportation

    Our Journalists

    • Rod Boshart
    • Erin Jordan
    • John Steppe
  • Obituaries
    • All Obituaries
    • In Memory Of
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Podcasts
    • All Podcasts
    • Daily News Podcast
    • Fact Checker
    • Hlastradamus Odds
    • Iowa Prep Sports
    • On Iowa
    • On Iowa Politics
    • On UNI
    • Pinning Combination
  • Entertainment
    • All Entertainment
    • Art
    • Books
    • Museums & Galleries
    • Music
    • Theater
    • Things To Do
  • Living
    • All Living
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Milestones
    • People & Places
    • Pets & Animals
    • Recreation
    • Religion & Belief
    • Travel

    Our Writers

    • Diana Nollen
    • Elijah Decious
  • Kids Gazette
    • See All
    • Kids Cooking Series
    • Kids Galleries
    • Printables
    • Activities
    • Articles
    • Submissions
    • Resources
  • Photos
    • All Photos and Videos
    • The Iowa Photo
    • Photo Store

    Our Photojournalists

    • Andy Abeyta
    • Liz Martin
    • Rebecca Miller
    • Jim Slosiarek
    • Gazette Visuals
  • Milestones
    • All Milestones
    • Anniversaries
    • Days To Remember
    • Engagements
    • Holidays
    • In Remembrance
    • New Arrivals
    • Thank Yous
    • Submit a Milestone
  • Data
    • Arrests
    • Building Permits
    • Interactive Maps & Charts
    • Salaries
  • Gazette Sites
    • Classifieds
    • Corridor Careers
    • Garage Sales
    • Gazette Gives Back
    • Gazette Rewards
    • Gazette Store
    • Green Gazette
    • HER
    • Iowa Wedding Experience
    • Holiday Light Finder
    • Hoopla
    • Iowa Ideas
    • Photo Store
  • Special Events
  • Special Sections
  • Other
    • About The Gazette
    • Archives
    • Article Removal
    • Business Directory
    • CR Arrest Database
    • Mobile Apps
    • Customer Care
    • Order Back Issues
    • Privacy Policies
    • Puzzle Answers
    • Sponsorship Requests
    • Submit a Letter
    • Weather
  • Digital Edition
Daily News PodcastDaily News Podcast
Daily NewslettersDaily Newsletters
Log out

FOLLOW US

The Gazette
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Food and Drink
  • Business
  • Obituaries
  • Podcasts
  • Entertainment
  • Living
  • Kids Gazette
  • Photos
  • Milestones
  • Data
  • Gazette Sites
  • Special Events
  • Special Sections
  • Other
  • Digital Edition
  • All News
  • Election 2020
  • Coronavirus
  • Business News
  • Community
  • Crime and Courts
  • Education
  • Government
  • Health
  • Nation and World
  • Time Machine
  • Search Archive

Our Journalists

  • Rod Boshart
  • Lee Hermiston
  • Erin Jordan
  • James Q. Lynch
  • Trish Mehaffey
  • Vanessa Miller
  • Kat Russell
  • Grace King
  • John Steppe
  • Gage Miskimen
  • Marissa Payne
  • All Sports
  • Iowa Hawkeyes
  • Hawkeye Football
  • Hawkeye Basketball
  • Prep Sports
  • Prep Volleyball
  • Prep Football
  • Prep Basketball
  • Prep Wrestling
  • Iowa State Cyclones
  • UNI Panthers
  • Small College Sports
  • Minor League Sports
  • Outdoors

Sports Desk

  • Mike Hlas
  • Jeff Johnson
  • Jeff Linder
  • J.R. Ogden
  • K.J. Pilcher
  • Leah Vann
  • All Opinion
  • Editorial Mission
  • Guest Columnists
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Political Cartoons
  • Staff Columnists
  • Staff Editorials
  • Submit a Letter or Column

Our Columnists

  • Todd Dorman
  • Adam Sullivan
  • All Food and Drink
  • Chew on This
  • Recipes
  • Restaurants
  • All Business
  • Agriculture
  • Business Notes
  • Companies
  • Personal Finance
  • Economy
  • Employment
  • Energy
  • Manufacturing
  • Openings & Closures
  • Real Estate
  • Retail
  • Small Business
  • Transportation

Our Journalists

  • Rod Boshart
  • Erin Jordan
  • John Steppe
  • All Obituaries
  • In Memory Of
  • Submit an Obituary
  • All Podcasts
  • Daily News Podcast
  • Fact Checker
  • Hlastradamus Odds
  • Iowa Prep Sports
  • On Iowa
  • On Iowa Politics
  • On UNI
  • Pinning Combination
  • All Entertainment
  • Art
  • Books
  • Museums & Galleries
  • Music
  • Theater
  • Things To Do
  • All Living
  • Health & Wellness
  • Home & Garden
  • Milestones
  • People & Places
  • Pets & Animals
  • Recreation
  • Religion & Belief
  • Travel

Our Writers

  • Diana Nollen
  • Elijah Decious
  • See All
  • Kids Cooking Series
  • Kids Galleries
  • Printables
  • Activities
  • Articles
  • Submissions
  • Resources
  • All Photos and Videos
  • The Iowa Photo
  • Photo Store

Our Photojournalists

  • Andy Abeyta
  • Liz Martin
  • Rebecca Miller
  • Jim Slosiarek
  • Gazette Visuals
  • All Milestones
  • Anniversaries
  • Days To Remember
  • Engagements
  • Holidays
  • In Remembrance
  • New Arrivals
  • Thank Yous
  • Submit a Milestone
  • Arrests
  • Building Permits
  • Interactive Maps & Charts
  • Salaries
  • Classifieds
  • Corridor Careers
  • Garage Sales
  • Gazette Gives Back
  • Gazette Rewards
  • Gazette Store
  • Green Gazette
  • HER
  • Iowa Wedding Experience
  • Holiday Light Finder
  • Hoopla
  • Iowa Ideas
  • Photo Store
  • About The Gazette
  • Archives
  • Article Removal
  • Business Directory
  • CR Arrest Database
  • Mobile Apps
  • Customer Care
  • Order Back Issues
  • Privacy Policies
  • Puzzle Answers
  • Sponsorship Requests
  • Submit a Letter
  • Weather
Daily News PodcastDaily News Podcast Daily NewslettersDaily Newsletters
LOG OUT

FOLLOW US

More Stories

Police looking into death of teenage girl at Iowa hog…

Woman testifies former lover killed man over meth quality

University of Iowa education dean Daniel Clay named 4th finalist…

Tiki Tacos ’n Burgers ’n Wings brings island vibe to…

Ex-Iowa school janitor who sexually abused child gets prison

Highway 151 roadwork will close some lanes through fall

Iowa City Mosque damaged by fire

Watch: Gov. Kim Reynolds holds news conference at 11 a.m.…

Home / News / Government & Politics / Campaigns & Elections

Smaller states get bigger say in Electoral College

Vanessa MillerBy: Vanessa Miller Nov. 26, 2016 7:00 pm Updated: Nov. 26, 2016 5:56 pm
Smaller states get bigger say in Electoral College

A growing number of Americans — largely those who backed Hillary Clinton for president — are expressing frustration with the Electoral College after it again evinced victory for the candidate who lost the popular vote.

As Clinton's popular-vote margin over President-elect Donald Trump swells to more than 2 million — breaking the record for a candidate who will lose at the Electoral College when electors vote Dec. 19 — some voters, analysts and political scientists are arguing for rejection the winner-take-all approach. Some propose ditching entirely the constitutionally-established mechanism America's founders created for choosing presidents.

But experts and analysts across Iowa say that's unlikely to happen and perhaps shouldn't, especially when considering the best interests of rural states.

'It prevents large states like California from running roughshod over the interests of smaller states like Iowa or Wyoming,' said Hans Hassell, assistant professor of politics at Cornell College in Mount Vernon. 'It makes presidential candidates more likely to campaign in Iowa. If that wasn't the case, they would spent all their time in New York City and in California and in Texas.

'The Electoral College really provides an option for us in Iowa to make a difference,' Hassell said. 'And, as an Iowan, I think that's important.'

As outlined in the Constitution, each state is represented in the Electoral College by its number of congressional representatives, plus two for both its senators.

The number of congressional representatives awarded each state is based on population determined every decade by the Census Bureau.

Because Iowa has four congressional districts, it gets six votes in the Electoral College, making it worthy of a candidate's consideration.

But, Hassell noted, the Electoral College's function today is not necessarily what the founders had in mind.

Their aim, he said, was primarily to prevent unwieldy factions from gaining momentum and voting into power someone to the detriment of the larger public good.

'They were concerned about these movements that would sweep up the nation and cause people to take rash action,' he said. 'So the Electoral College was situated with the idea that the electors are somewhat refined individuals that are trusted by the population in that particular state.'

These days, Hassell said, 'Most of the electors are party loyalists who have some sort of network within the party apparatus.'

Giving up power?

When the elector mechanism was established, citizens were more concerned with state identity — and thus state consensus — than some might be today, said University of Iowa political science professor Cary Covington.

'People now are thinking more as Americans rather than Virginians, for example,' he said.

Because the Constitution assigns to each state a number of Electoral College votes equal to its congressional districts — and thus population — Covington said that part of the equation accords with the 'one person, one vote' principle.

But 'in contrast, every state gets two electoral votes for its senators regardless of the size of its population, which violates that principle,' according to Covington.

'Each voter in a 'small population' state casts a larger share of those two electoral votes than does a voter in a 'larger population' state,' he said.

Covington calculated the departure from the one-person, one-vote principle per state by dividing electoral votes by population, and then doing so nationally.

His state-by-state comparison shows, for example, that Washington and Tennessee have per capita shares exactly aligned with the national average. Iowa has an advantage at 114 percent of the national average. Wyoming's per capita share is more than three times the national average, while California has the weakest share.

'So giving all states two electoral votes regardless of their population means that voters from small population states cast significantly more per capita electoral votes than do voters from large states,' Covington said.

And, without knowing the outcome of a particular election, most people today would say it makes sense for the electoral vote to reflect the popular vote, he said.

'Given the evolution in the way we think about who's represented in the Electoral College, it makes more and more sense that we should do something to make sure the Electoral College represents the popular vote,' he said. 'But how we do that is a whole different question.'

It's one that doesn't have an easy answer — or, perhaps, any answer.

'The only way to change it is with a constitutional amendment,' Covington said — which would require approval from 38 states.

'The smallest ones are never going to ratify the amendment that would take away their clout,' he said. 'Why would they give up that power?'

'KIND OF STUCK WITH IT'

Covington said he has spent years defending the Electoral College precisely because it gives voice to the nation's smaller states.

But, he said, 'Given the frequency now with which the electoral mechanism translates the popular vote into electoral votes, we really do need to as a nation recognize that the president is the representative of the nation as a whole.'

Four times in history has a presidential candidate won the popular vote but lost the office, according to U.S. House archives,

In 1824, John Quincy Adams was chosen president by the House after Andrew Jackson won the popular vote but not a majority of Electoral College votes. In 1876, Samuel Tilden won the popular vote but in a compromise over undecided votes in the Electoral College, the presidency went to Rutherford B. Hayes.

The episodes more comparable with this year's election were in 1888 when Benjamin Harrison lost the popular vote to Grover Cleveland but won the Electoral College, and in 2000 when George W. Bush narrowly lost the popular vote but beat Al Gore in the Electoral College.

Gore's popular-vote lead over Bush was about 540,000 votes, compared with Clinton's more than 2 million vote gap in this election.

Mack Shelley, professor and chair of the Iowa State University Department of Political Science, said the founders — in some sense — created the Electoral College in the image of a medieval rule for picking kings.

'When you think about how the Electoral College works, it's just about literally like a 12th century council of elders that picks the next monarch,' he said. 'I think it was meant to be almost exactly that.'

Except, he said, even in the 1800s, 'This was already a dying idea.'

'But we're kind of stuck with it,' he said. 'I think it would take a herculean effort and probably a whole bunch more elections where the popular electoral votes go haywire before anybody would have an interest.'

Since Trump's victory, several petitions and efforts have emerged to persuade electors to go against their state's majority — as not all states have laws against it.

But Shelley said he doesn't that's realistic.

'These people are picked as electors by the party leadership, and sometimes they actually are party leaders themselves,' he said.

Electors who do so essentially would give up any political aspirations.

'Your career is almost literally dead in your party at that point,' Shelley said.

l Comments: (319) 339-3158; vanessa.miller@thegazette.com

Hillary Clinton speaks at a campaign event in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States, March 28, 2016. REUTERS/Jim Young/File Photo
Vanessa Miller

Vanessa Miller

Reporter, The Gazette

Higher education reporter for The Gazette in Eastern Iowa. I love news tips, story ideas and reader feedback.

University of Iowa education dean Daniel Clay named 4th finalist…

University of Iowa among hospitals suing feds over organ-donation changes

3rd University of Iowa presidential finalist vows to tackle diversity,…

University of Iowa 3rd presidential finalist: Georgia State Provost Wendy…

Michael Richards, reappointed to the Board of Regents

All articles by Vanessa

Give us feedback

We work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage because we value your trust. If you find an error or omission in our reporting, please tell us here.

Submit a story idea

Do you have a story idea that we should look into? Please tell us here.

Related Stories

Iowa Democrats conducting 2020 autopsy with eye toward 2022, new…

Iowa Democrats conducting 2020 autopsy with eye toward 2022, new…

Erin Murphy Government & Politics Feb. 5, 2021 9:54 pm

Mariannette Miller-Meeks’ attorney: Request for rejected ballots ‘normal due diligence’

Mariannette Miller-Meeks’ attorney: Request for rejected ballots ‘normal due diligence’

By Tom Barton, Quad-City Times Government & Politics Feb. 5, 2021 9:53 pm

Bar owner Jake Brummer to run for Cedar Rapids mayor

Bar owner Jake Brummer to run for Cedar Rapids mayor

Marissa Payne Government & Politics Mar. 25, 2021 2:18 pm

Campaigns & Elections

Marion City Council members seek reelection

Marion City Council members seek reelection

Gage Miskimen

Local Government Apr. 18, 2021 11:58 pm

Iowa’s top election official ’comfortable’ that new law won’t suppress…

Iowa’s top election official ’comfortable’ that new law won’t suppress…

Erin Murphy

State Government Apr. 18, 2021 11:54 pm

Janelle Rettig announces she’s no longer a Johnson County supervisor

Janelle Rettig announces she’s no longer a Johnson County supervisor

Gazette staff

News Apr. 18, 2021 3:47 pm

Crackdowns on advance voting belie growing popularity among all voters

Crackdowns on advance voting belie growing popularity among all voters

AP

News Apr. 16, 2021 5:19 pm

News

Tanager Place raises awareness for Mental Health Month

Tanager Place raises awareness for Mental Health Month

Community 20m ago

University of Iowa education dean Daniel Clay named 4th finalist…

University of Iowa education dean Daniel Clay named 4th finalist…

Vanessa Miller

Higher Ed 29m ago

Ex-Iowa school janitor who sexually abused child gets prison

Ex-Iowa school janitor who sexually abused child gets prison

AP

Crime and Courts 42m ago

Police looking into death of teenage girl at Iowa hog…

Police looking into death of teenage girl at Iowa hog…

AP

News 2h ago

Government & Politics

Watch: Gov. Kim Reynolds holds news conference at 11 a.m.…

Watch: Gov. Kim Reynolds holds news conference at 11 a.m.…

The Gazette

Health Care and Medicine 3h ago

How to improve Iowa’s bottle bill? Raise handling fee, allow…

How to improve Iowa’s bottle bill? Raise handling fee, allow…

James Q. Lynch

Government & Politics Apr. 20, 2021 7:29 pm

Iowa Legislature approves end of schools’ voluntary diversity programs

Iowa Legislature approves end of schools’ voluntary diversity programs

James Q. Lynch

State Government Apr. 20, 2021 6:57 pm

U.S. Rep. Cindy Axne, Iowa Democrats ask feds to investigate…

U.S. Rep. Cindy Axne, Iowa Democrats ask feds to investigate…

Erin Jordan

State Government Apr. 20, 2021 2:49 pm

Sports

Capable shooting guards available for Iowa to replace CJ Fredrick

Capable shooting guards available for Iowa to replace CJ Fredrick

Mike Hlas

Hawkeye Basketball 1h ago

Prairie girls take their shot at unprecedented Drake Relays glory

Prairie girls take their shot at unprecedented Drake Relays glory

Jeff Linder

High School Track and Field 4h ago

Iowa talks ’next men up’ mentality at tight end, defensive…

Iowa talks ’next men up’ mentality at tight end, defensive…

Leah Vann

Hawkeye Football Apr. 21, 2021 12:28 am

Xavier boys’ soccer on a mission in 2021

Xavier boys’ soccer on a mission in 2021

Nathan Ford

High School Soccer 4h ago

FOLLOW US

The Gazette is Iowa’s independent, employee-owned source for local, state, and national news coverage.

© 2021 The Gazette

All Rights Reserved.

  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy
  • Web Accessibility

Contact Us

  • 116 3rd St SE
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52401
  • customercare@thegazette.com
  • (319) 398-8333
  • Live Chat

Links

  • Puzzle Answers
  • CR Arrest Database
  • Article Removal Request
  • Gazette Archives
  • Green Gazette
  • Corridor Careers Jobs
  • Work at The Gazette
  • Customer Care

© 2021 The Gazette

All Rights Reserved.

  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy
  • Web Accessibility
Folience A Folience Company