Like what you're reading?

We make it easy to stay connected:

to our email newsletters
Download our free apps

Closing this prison doesn't add up

The Gazette Editorial Board


Some state leaders have been trying to shut down Luster Heights Prison Camp for a decade. And now the governor’s proposed budget again has the Allamakee County facility up for closure.

It’s part of cost-saving efforts, moving money to other prisons in the state system. Laudable. But closing this correctional facility looks counterproductive.

Consider what The Gazette recently reported about the 88-bed, minimum-security prison:

l Inmates get to Luster Heights because they’ve earned it through positive behavior in higher-security prisons.

l Despite no fence or security guards, there have not been any walk-offs in the last eight years.

l The annual cost to keep an inmate at Luster Heights is under $20,000, while the statewide average is more than $30,000 — a difference of about $800,000 per year.

l Some of the savings is because of self-sufficiency practices. For example, wood cut by the inmates provides 95 percent of the facility’s heat. Produce raised helps hold down the food bills.

l Inmate labor helps the county’s conservation and roads departments, as well as the city of Waukon, save tens of thousands of taxpayer dollars.

l Inmates also assist state foresters with planting replacement trees and maintaining trails in the nearby Yellow River State Forest.

l Most noteworthy: 85 percent of the inmates participate in drug treatment. Once released, 22.7 percent reoffend and return to prison within three years; the statewide rate is 31.8 percent.

Gosh — treatment and work experience that helps offenders be more likely to succeed when re-entering society, all at a lower cost to the state while also assisting local governments. Does it really make sense to “save” the state’s annual appropriation of $1.6 million for Luster Heights? Isn’t the real savings already happening?

Are we missing something here? Or is the governor’s office?

l Comments: or (319) 398-8262

Give us feedback

Have you found an error or omission in our reporting? Tell us here.
Do you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.